ARC Review: The Clergyman’s Wife by Molly Greeley

The Clergyman's Wife


Charlotte Collins, nee Lucas, is the respectable wife of Hunsford’s vicar, and sees to her duties by rote: keeping house, caring for their adorable daughter, visiting parishioners, and patiently tolerating the lectures of her awkward husband and his condescending patroness, Lady Catherine de Bourgh. Intelligent, pragmatic, and anxious to escape the shame of spinsterhood, Charlotte chose this life, an inevitable one so socially acceptable that its quietness threatens to overwhelm her. Then she makes the acquaintance of Mr. Travis, a local farmer and tenant of Lady Catherine..
In Mr. Travis’ company, Charlotte feels appreciated, heard, and seen. For the first time in her life, Charlotte begins to understand emotional intimacy and its effect on the heart—and how breakable that heart can be. With her sensible nature confronted, and her own future about to take a turn, Charlotte must now question the role of love and passion in a woman’s life, and whether they truly matter for a clergyman’s wife.


The only classics I really loved are Jane Austen’s books and I’ve read them many many times, so these days it’s much more exciting for me to find contemporary authors reimagining her books or characters. And this book fascinated me right from the time I saw it on Edelweiss, because when have we ever thought more about Charlotte’s life after her marriage to Mr. Collins. I was very happy when I received this advance copy and I devoured this in just a few hours.


This is the author’s debut novel but you probably wouldn’t be able to guess that because the prose is absolutely beautiful and lyrical and so many other adjectives which I don’t even know. While I couldn’t put the book down  at all, it is by no means a fast paced novel. It’s slow and languid and has a melancholic aesthetic to it, and you can feel every single feeling that the author wants you to. Days go by and the seasons change and that atmosphere is so perfectly captured that it amazed me. I also thought the author wrote about Charlotte’s loneliness in a way that deeply resonated with me.

It also helps that the author knows her P&P characters well and even though she is writing her own backstory and future story for them, you feel that these are the same people whom you have known since you first read the original and you are just getting to know them better now. I think it’s difficult to create a new story with familiar characters without being too disruptive, and I love that the author managed to create a perfect balance.


I’m pretty sure most of us pitied Charlotte for choosing marry Mr. Collins, maybe even looked down on her for compromising – but she knows what she did and why she had to make those choices. We get to know her so much more better in this book – her childhood dreams, the moment she realized she was never going to be a catch, and her decision to choose comfort and security over love.

She is a very kind hearted woman who is trying to make the best of her life, but there are also moments of self reflection, pain and loneliness, of thinking about what-ifs and wondering what more she can do. And the time when she realizes what emotional intimacy can feel like, what does it feel like to be seen and heard – her heartache and confusion was very poignant and beautifully written. I have to say I really empathized with her a lot and only wanted her to be happy.

Mr. Collins is the same person we know, giving his long winding opinions on everything and being extra deferential towards Lady Catherine. And while he can be annoying as ever, seeing him through Charlotte’s eyes brings a certain humanity to his character. He is not someone who is expressive or good at communicating true feelings, but she manages to get little glimpses of his true self and I thought that was done so sensitively.

Lady Catherine is her usual obnoxious self and  I don’t think anyone can make her seem more sympathetic. I loved the two newly added characters Mr. Travis and Mrs. Fitzgibbon and the lovely friendship and companionship they brought to Charlotte, who was so starved for affection. And I was totally delighted to see her daughter Louisa grow up within the pages of the book. And I won’t deny that getting to meet Lizzy and Mr. Darcy was amazing, even if just for a couple of scenes.


To conclude, if you love Austen retellings or spinoffs, you should definitely try this book. It’s beautiful and evocative and completely captured my heart. I was probably in a fragile emotional state while reading it (and needed some catharsis it looks like) because I wept and wept through most of the second half. It’s not a sad book per se, but it does have a bit of that feeling permeating throughout – and while it made me cry, I don’t think it’ll elicit the same reaction in everyone. I’m so glad that I got the opportunity to read this book and I’m very much looking forward to see what the author writes next.

untitled design (7)

PS: Thank you to Edelweiss and William Morrow for providing me with this advance copy. All opinions expressed here are unbiased and solely mine.

15 thoughts on “ARC Review: The Clergyman’s Wife by Molly Greeley

Add yours

  1. Ahhh Sahi, you pull at the strings of my heart. I’ve never read a single JA book, but your love for the classics (including the Mahabharata) and dragging me along with you. I’m mere granules of sand to your tide 😭😭😭.

    I get what you mean, about how the book doesn’t feel like a debut. Haven’t you felt that recently a lot of debut books are sounding so mature and well written and just getting us to bawl our eyes out. I know what you mean, about the book not being sad exactly, but having hit the right mark.

    Loved your review Sahi!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Haha Ahana.. except a few JA books and Sherlock, I hate classics 😂😂😂 Mahabharata is a whole other thing.. that’s my life !!!!
      I completely agree… the debuts these days are just beautifully written and I can hardly find any faults in them… and this one really hit that mark in my heart…

      Liked by 1 person

        1. Lol that’s why I don’t even try to write anything original… I’m so not creative… I’m just happy writing about the wonderful books everyone else is writing 😍😍😍

          Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Start a Blog at

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: